logo
Practitioner's log inFind your match
logo
Why 'New Year, Same Me' Could Be Your Best Resolution in 2025 - Therapist Guide

New Year, Same Me: Why Intentions Outshine Resolutions?

91% of New Year's resolutions fail. Why? Because change isn't about becoming someone new—it's about understanding who you already are. Dr Nicole Nasr reveals how to create meaningful transformation by embracing your authentic self in 2025.

How often have you told yourself, “This is the year”?

Feeling confident you will stick to the usual New Year goals? Yet, by mid-February, statistics show that 91% of New Year resolution attempts end in disappointment.

So, why does this happen year after year?

We spoke with Dr Nicole Nasr, therapist and founder of Journey. She suggests a radical shift in how we think about change. Instead of chasing the "New Year, New Me" fantasy, she advocates for something different: "New Year, Same Me." The idea isn't to reinvent yourself but to understand and nurture who you already are.

Dr Nicole Nasr:
"There is something about beginnings that gives us the impression of a clean slate. It’s a social construct that comes with its own energy. Unfortunately, what we don’t realize is that any pursuit based on such a shallow motivation—like the ‘clean slate’ effect—just isn’t strong enough to sustain real changes.”

Why “New Year, New Me” Isn't Always Helpful?

Dr Nasr reveals how our well-intentioned push for total transformation can hinder real growth. Here's what gets in our way:

  • Feeling Overwhelmed: Lofty resolutions—losing 20 pounds, reading 50 books, a marathon— while ignoring the how and why behind these goals.

  • Change Doesn't Happen Overnight: You are the same person on January 1st as on December 31st. Actual growth happens by evolving your core self, not reinventing it.

  • Life Is Unpredictable: Rigid plans crumble when life throws curveballs, leaving you feeling like a failure.

Why Do Your Resolutions Feel Empty?

Common goals fail when they don't address the deeper why. Targeting the root reason behind behaviours ensures changes are sustainable.

Dr Nicole Nasr:
If the reason you smoke is tied to not knowing how to regulate your nervous system, and your nervous system is constantly triggered for some reason… you need to address that reason. Otherwise, the smoking habit just returns.

The Secret to Resolutions That Stick

Instead of vague resolutions, Dr Nasr suggests to ask yourself:

What's behind the goal?
For instance, losing weight may mean seeking more energy to enjoy life. Why do you want that energy? Dig deeper until you uncover the true intention.
Focus on the feeling you want.
To “feel alive,” explore activities that genuinely resonate with you, like dancing, morning walks, or cooking healthy meals—not just hitting a target weight.
Reframe the goal to intention.
Turn “I want to lose weight” into “I want to feel more energized and vibrant in my body.” shifting the focus to a broader, more meaningful aim.

When you identify the intention behind your goals, possibilities expand. Living with intention also removes pressure from a resolution's “deadline.” If you miss a day of exercise, you are not “failing” your goal. You are simply finding another way to stay aligned with your deeper purpose.

How to Stop the Cycle of Restarting Every Year?

Feeling like you must start over each year can hurt your self-esteem.

Dr Nicole Nasr:
It gives this false impression that if you’re not able to maintain your resolutions, it’s because you are not disciplined enough. In reality, you might just be chasing a goal for reasons that aren’t genuine to you—or you haven’t addressed what’s really driving your behavior.

So rather than wiping the slate clean, Dr Nasr recommends an end-of-year reflection:

Dr Nicole Nasr:
I see what helped and what didn’t, what I have learned and what I’m still curious about. It’s more useful than forcing an entirely ‘new me’ on January 1st.

Acknowledging who you are today—your strengths, weaknesses, and aspirations—can help you evolve naturally. Focusing on why you want specific changes and letting that intention guide you will make your resolutions flexible and deeply personal.

How to Start Evolving in 2025?

  • Reflect, Don't Resolve: What brought you joy or stress last year? Identify patterns to shift gently.

  • Ask Why: Drill into your motivations. If you want to run a 5K, is it to feel strong or for external validation?

  • Start Small: Try habits like offering daily compliments—to yourself or others—to spark positive change.

  • Practice Self-Compassion: Acknowledge setbacks, adjust your approach, and keep going.

You are a mountain filled with fog. Growth reveals your immensity. Nothing bad comes from uncovering your true self.
Dr Nicole Nasr

This year, skip the “New Year, New Me” frenzy.
Focus on deepening your understanding of the person you already are.
Real change begins with intention, and the results will follow when you find that.